By the fourth Thanksgiving, Eli had developed a habit.
Whenever Danielle spoke to him, he looked at me.
Not every time.
Just often enough for me to notice.
If she asked him whether he wanted something, he checked my expression first.
If she made a comment about his father, he watched my face before answering.
If the adults laughed, he sometimes looked around to see whether he was supposed to laugh too.
I hated seeing that.
I hated knowing that a child who should have been thinking about toys and cartoons was trying to understand the moods of grown people.
That year, I had brought a pie.
Nothing special.
I had bought it from the grocery store because work had been busy, and I hadn't had time to bake.
Eli carried the empty pie box into the house.
He was proud of helping.
Lucy met him in the hallway.
"Come upstairs. I made something."
He looked at me.
I smiled.
"Go ahead."
He ran after her.
I found my mother in the kitchen.
She was preparing vegetables and asking whether anyone had remembered to bring extra napkins.
I started helping.
For a while, everything seemed normal.
Then Danielle came in.
She opened the refrigerator, looked at the containers, and asked whether I had brought anything.
I pointed toward the pie.
She glanced at the box.
"Store-bought?"
I shrugged.
"I didn't have time."
She smiled.
"Some people always seem to have an excuse."
I put the knife down.
"Danielle, please."
She raised both hands.
"What? I was asking."
I knew that expression.
She used it whenever she wanted to say something cruel without accepting responsibility for it.
Mom turned on the kitchen faucet.
The water ran longer than necessary.
Nobody said anything.
I went upstairs to check on Eli.
He and Lucy were sitting on the floor, building something with blankets and cushions.
Lucy had placed two red game pieces beside them.
"These are yours," she told him.
Eli smiled.
I stood in the doorway longer than I needed to.
He looked happy.
That was the picture I wanted to keep.
At dinner, Danielle made another remark about how Lucy had a proper family structure.
She didn't say my name.
She didn't need to.
I put my fork down.
"Can we have one holiday without doing this?"
She looked surprised.
"Doing what?"
"Making comments about my son."
"Oh, Jenna."
She laughed.
It was a small laugh.
The kind that made it sound as though I had embarrassed myself.
Dad shook his head.
"Not tonight."
I looked at him.
"Then tell her to stop."
He didn't answer.
Mom began asking someone about their drive home.
The conversation changed.
Again.
I watched Eli.
He had stopped eating.
His eyes moved from Danielle to me.
I smiled at him and asked whether he wanted another roll.
He nodded.
And I hated myself for how quickly I had learned to make things look normal.
After dinner, I started packing our things.
Eli was upstairs with Lucy.
I folded his jacket over my arm and put his small bag beside the door.
Mom noticed.
"You're leaving already?"
"Yes."
She looked toward the dining room.
"Jenna, don't make this bigger than it needs to be."
I didn't answer immediately.
Then I said something I should have said years earlier.
"She's hurting my child."
Mom looked down.
"I know Danielle can be difficult."
"That's not what I said."
She reached for my arm.
"Let me talk to her."
I wanted to believe her.
I wanted my mother to understand that this wasn't about two sisters disagreeing.
It was about a little boy learning what his family thought of him.
"I'll speak to her before Christmas," Mom promised.
I nodded.
I waited a moment before going upstairs.
Lucy was still playing with Eli.
She had placed the red game pieces in front of him.
He was explaining something about the little blanket house.
When I told him it was time to go, he asked whether we could stay longer.
I said we had school the next morning.
He accepted that.
Children often accept explanations because they don't know what else to do.
In the car, he asked whether we would see Lucy again.
"Of course."
"When?"
"Maybe Christmas."
He looked out the window.
Then he asked something that stayed with me.
"Does Aunt Danielle not like me?"
I kept both hands on the steering wheel.
"She needs to learn how to speak kindly."
He thought about that.
"Did I do something?"
"No, sweetheart."
I said it immediately.
Too quickly.
"You didn't do anything wrong."
He nodded.
I drove home with the radio off.
For the next few weeks, I waited for Mom to call.
She didn't.
I considered calling her myself.
I even picked up my phone one evening after Eli went to bed.
But I put it down.
I had already explained the problem.
I shouldn't have needed to explain it again.
Christmas came.
Mom invited us over.
I asked whether Danielle had apologized.
Mom said she had spoken to her.
I asked what Danielle had said.
There was a pause.
"She thinks you misunderstood her."
I closed my eyes.
"Of course she does."
"Jenna, please. Let's just have a nice Christmas."
I should have refused.
Instead, I agreed to come for a few hours.
That was how it went in our family.
The person who caused the problem stayed comfortable.
The person who objected was asked to be reasonable.
Christmas passed without a major argument.
Danielle was polite enough.
She asked Eli about school.
She complimented his sweater.
She even gave him a small gift.
He thanked her.
I watched her carefully.
She never mentioned Thanksgiving.
Neither did anyone else.
For a while, I thought perhaps Mom had managed to get through to her.
Then another family gathering came.
And Danielle made another comment.
Not loud.
Not dramatic.
Just something placed into the conversation so casually that objecting would make me look unreasonable.
I told her I didn't appreciate it.
She said I was too sensitive.
Dad told us to stop.
Mom looked at me.
I recognized the expression before she even spoke.
She wanted me to let it go.
I did.
Again.
The months passed.
Eli grew taller.
He started asking for things his classmates had.
A particular backpack.
A pair of shoes.
A soccer uniform.
I checked the prices and worked them into the budget.
We had ordinary problems.
A leaking bathroom faucet.
A school form I forgot to sign.
A week when work became overwhelming.
Those were problems I could solve.
Danielle was different.
I couldn't make her treat my child with basic respect.
And I couldn't understand why my parents kept expecting me to accept it.
Sometimes I thought about Grandma Rose.
I remembered her hand around my wrist.
I remembered how she used to tell Danielle that being older didn't make her right.
But Grandma wasn't there anymore.
And I was beginning to understand that the family had been depending on her to be the person who spoke up.
Without her, everybody had become quieter.
Especially when Danielle was involved.
Click here to continue reading: PART 3: My Son Started Reading the Room Before He Read the Faces Around the Thanksgiving Table
I Kept Bringing My Son to a House Where His Own Aunt Made Him Feel Like He Didn’t Belong
Part 2 of 20
