PART 7 – My Attorney Asked the Questions I Had Been Carrying for Months, and the Three Photographs Finally Had a Purpose

The courtroom took a short pause.

People shifted in their seats.

Papers moved across the tables.

I stayed where I was.

My attorney leaned toward me.

"You doing okay?"

I nodded.

I wasn't sure that was true.

But I didn't want him worrying about me when he had enough to think about.

I looked toward Rachel.

She was speaking quietly to Quinn.

The little girl seemed calmer now.

I was glad.

I kept thinking about the photographs on my phone.

I had taken them without knowing whether anyone would ever look at them.

At the time, I had simply wanted a record.

I hadn't imagined a courtroom.

I hadn't imagined a lawsuit.

And I certainly hadn't imagined Wayne Haller sitting across from me demanding a quarter of a million dollars.

When the proceedings continued, my attorney returned to his questions.

He focused on what I had actually done that afternoon.

He wanted the court to understand the difference between stopping somebody physically and standing near an exit because a child was frightened.

That difference mattered.

I remembered exactly where I had stood.

I remembered keeping my hands away from Wayne.

I remembered stepping aside when Mr. Darby ordered me to move.

I had not grabbed him.

I had not pushed him.

I had not touched his arm.

My attorney spoke carefully.

He explained that I had been concerned about Quinn's statements and had called for help.

Wayne's lawyer disagreed.

He continued describing my actions as harassment.

I felt my face grow hot again.

It was difficult to sit quietly while someone described an afternoon I had experienced differently.

But I kept my hands folded.

My attorney then addressed the photographs.

He referred to the pictures I'd taken in the parking lot.

I remembered opening my phone that day.

My fingers had been shaking.

I had tried to make sure the license plate was readable.

I had taken the man's face because I thought someone might need to identify him.

I had photographed Quinn through the window because she was the child who had been crying.

Nothing about it had been complicated.

I wasn't collecting evidence for a lawsuit.

I wasn't trying to embarrass Wayne.

I had simply been worried.

The judge asked a question about the photographs.

My attorney answered.

Then he returned to the timeline.

The man had approached the exit carrying Quinn.

Quinn had said he wasn't her father.

She had mentioned Patricia Corliss.

I had asked for help from my manager.

My manager had told me to step aside.

I had done so.

Then I had taken the photographs and called 911.

That was the sequence.

I wanted it to remain clear.

Because the lawsuit had turned those ordinary actions into something they weren't.

I looked toward Wayne.

His lawyer was writing something on a legal pad.

Wayne leaned over to him.

They spoke quietly.

I couldn't hear them.

Then my attorney asked to address the accusation that I had grabbed Wayne's arm.

He made it clear that I denied touching him.

I had denied it from the beginning.

I had never changed my account.

I had never added details to make myself look better.

I had only repeated what happened.

Wayne's lawyer looked toward me.

He seemed irritated.

I wondered whether he believed his client's version.

I wondered whether he had ever considered that an older woman working at a store might have been telling the truth.

The judge listened to both sides.

I tried to follow the discussion.

Some of the words were unfamiliar.

But the basic issue was easy to understand.

Wayne said I had harmed him.

I said I hadn't done what he accused me of.

And the events surrounding Quinn mattered because they explained why I had become involved in the first place.

My attorney returned to his seat.

He gave me a small nod.

I nodded back.

Then the judge turned toward the other table.

Wayne's lawyer began speaking again.

He argued that his client had been subjected to an embarrassing public incident.

He repeated that Wayne had identified himself as Quinn's father.

I remembered that moment.

He had shown the driver's license.

He had shown the photograph.

Mr. Darby had accepted both.

But neither item had answered the question Quinn had raised.

I thought about the little girl's words.

She hadn't said she didn't want to go shopping.

She hadn't said she wanted another toy.

She had said the man wasn't her father.

I remembered how certain she had sounded.

A three-year-old might not understand every adult situation.

But that didn't mean her fear should be ignored.

I looked toward Rachel again.

She was holding Quinn's hand now.

The child's pink boots rested against the floor.

I wondered whether Rachel knew how close I had come to simply returning to my position and doing nothing.

I had been frightened of losing my job.

I had been frightened of getting involved.

And I had been frightened of making a mistake.

I had moved aside because my manager told me to.

That decision still bothered me.

If I could return to that afternoon, I would have wanted somebody to take the child's words seriously before allowing the man to leave.

I couldn't change it.

But I could tell the truth about what I had seen.

My attorney asked the court to consider the circumstances surrounding the incident.

He didn't call me brave.

He didn't make me sound like somebody who had solved a crime.

He simply explained that I had acted out of concern for a distressed child.

I was grateful for that.

I didn't want a story about a hero.

I wanted the truth.

And for the first time, I felt the courtroom beginning to hear it.


Click here to continue reading: PART 8: When I Finally Looked at Quinn Again, I Realized the Little Sticker I Had Offered Her Meant More Than I Ever Expected

Story Parts

I Thought Greeting Customers Was the Safest Job I Could Have at Sixty-Seven, Until One Little Girl Grabbed My Vest

Part 7 of 20

Previous: Part 6
Next: Part 8

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *