I didn't want to embarrass anybody.
That was the first thing I told myself.
The second was that forty-five dollars wasn't going to ruin me.
I had worked too many years to become upset over one payment.
So I reached for my coin purse.
It was the same little purse I carried when I went shopping.
I opened it and took out two twenty-dollar bills.
Then I found a five.
I counted the money carefully.
Forty-five dollars.
Exactly what the card requested.
I placed it in front of Brittany.
"There you are, sweetheart."
Then I asked her for something.
"Would you mind giving me a receipt?"
She looked at me.
For the first time that afternoon, she seemed unsure what to say.
I don't know what she expected me to do.
Perhaps she expected an argument.
Perhaps she thought I would complain and eventually hand over the money anyway.
Instead, I waited.
She picked up the index card.
Then she wrote a word across it.
PAID.
She handed it back.
I took the card and put it in my purse.
I didn't throw it away.
I didn't leave it on the table.
I folded nothing.
I simply tucked it safely inside.
Then I ate my Thanksgiving dinner.
Every bite.
The turkey was fine.
The sides were fine.
The noodles I had brought were on the table.
The pies were there, too.
I had made both of them.
And somehow, I was paying to eat the dessert I had prepared.
I remember looking at the pecan pie.
I remember thinking about the time it had taken to make it.
I didn't say anything.
I finished my meal.
Nobody asked whether I was comfortable with the arrangement.
Nobody offered to return the money.
And Kyle never lifted his eyes long enough to meet mine.
That was the part I couldn't forget.
A mother can accept a lot of things from her grown children.
She can accept that they have their own households.
She can accept that their priorities change.
She can even accept that their wives might run the holidays differently.
But watching your own child sit quietly while somebody treats you like an unwanted guest is something else.
I kept that thought to myself.
When it was time to leave, I gathered my things and went home.
I drove with both hands on the steering wheel.
The road ahead was familiar.
I'd made that trip many times.
Usually, I thought about the grandchildren or what food might be needed for the next family gathering.
That evening, I thought about money.
Not just the forty-five dollars.
A much larger amount.
Because I had been helping Kyle for years.
And suddenly, I started adding everything together.
Five years earlier, Kyle had called me.
He had lost his job at the plant.
I remembered how worried he sounded.
He wasn't asking for something extravagant.
He wasn't asking me to buy him a new truck.
He wanted help keeping the family connected.
He asked whether I could add his household to my cell phone plan.
Just temporarily.
Until things improved.
I said yes.
Of course I did.
He was my son.
There were four lines involved.
I didn't mind helping.
At least, that was how I saw it.
I wasn't thinking about how long it might continue.
I wasn't calculating what it would cost over several years.
I was thinking about a son who needed help.
Two years later, another call came.
This time, it concerned Ron and Debbie.
Ron had lost access to his company phone.
Kyle asked whether I could add his wife's parents to my plan.
It would only be for a while, he said.
I agreed again.
That meant there were seven lines altogether, including mine.
Seven.
I had never really stopped to consider how many people depended on that account.
The monthly payment came out of my own account.
I handled it.
I didn't send everyone a separate bill.
I didn't ask them to reimburse me every month.
I simply paid it.
Then there was Kyle's truck.
I had helped put it on my car insurance because it worked out better for the discount.
That was another arrangement I had agreed to because it seemed helpful.
One favor became another.
One temporary arrangement became part of the monthly expenses.
And I kept paying.
About three hundred and ten dollars every month.
I repeated that amount in my head.
Three hundred and ten.
Every month.
Not once.
Not twice.
Month after month.
I had been paying for the phone lines and helping with the insurance.
And Brittany thought Kyle was paying the phone bill.
Kyle had never corrected her.
Ron and Debbie believed the same thing.
They assumed the account belonged to Kyle.
They didn't know I was the one whose money was leaving the bank every month.
I don't know why that bothered me so much on the drive home.
Maybe because I had just paid forty-five dollars to eat at a table where I had been helping support several of the people sitting around it.
Maybe because I had expected gratitude and received a bill instead.
Or maybe I was finally seeing how comfortable everybody had become with my help.
I had never asked for recognition.
That was true.
But I had also never imagined that my generosity would become invisible.
By the time I reached home, I had done the arithmetic several times.
The forty-five dollars was one thing.
The three hundred and ten dollars was another.
And the difference between those numbers stayed with me.
I parked.
I carried my things inside.
The house was quiet.
There was no husband waiting to ask how Thanksgiving had gone.
There was nobody sitting at the kitchen table.
I put my purse down.
The index card was still inside.
I took it out and looked at Brittany's handwriting.
My name.
The food.
The amount.
And the word PAID.
I could have thrown it away.
Instead, I left it where I could see it.
Then I picked up the phone and called my sister.
Dot had always been somebody I could talk to.
She knew our family.
She knew Kyle.
And she knew how much I had tried to help everybody.
When she answered, I didn't waste time pretending everything was fine.
I told her what happened.
"Dot, Brittany charged me forty-five dollars for Thanksgiving dinner."
There was a pause.
Then she asked me to repeat myself.
I did.
I told her about the card.
I told her about Ron and Debbie eating without paying.
I told her I had handed over the cash.
Dot was quiet for a moment.
Then she asked the question that made me realize just how strange the whole arrangement had become.
"Georgia Ann, are you still paying Ron Schaefer's phone bill?"
I told her yes.
She couldn't believe it.
Then she reminded me of something.
Ron owned a bass boat.
I sat there holding the phone.
I wasn't angry at the boat.
I wasn't angry that Ron had something nice.
But I couldn't help noticing the difference.
I was paying for his phone while he enjoyed his own things.
And I had just been charged for Thanksgiving dinner.
Dot understood why I was upset.
I didn't have to explain every little detail.
For once, somebody wasn't telling me to let it go.
Click here to continue reading: PART 3: When I Finally Asked My Son About the Monthly Bills, His Wife Answered Before He Could Say a Word
The Little Card Beside My Plate Made Me Question Everything I Thought I Knew About Being Family
Part 2 of 20
