Jillian kept staring at the title.
I could see her reading the same lines over and over.
Her name wasn't there.
Mine was.
The credit union had confirmed that the loan was paid in full, and the vehicle information matched the gray SUV sitting in her driveway.
She looked up at me.
"Mama, are you telling me I don't own my own car?"
I folded my hands.
"I'm telling you the paperwork says what it says."
She pushed the document toward Greg.
"Look at this."
He picked it up.
He read the first page, then the second.
Finally, he nodded.
"It's the title, Jill."
She looked irritated.
"I know what a title is."
"Then you understand what it says."
She turned toward me again.
"Why would you do this to me?"
I felt that question more than I expected.
Why would I do this to her?
I had spent three years helping her.
Three years of payments.
Three years of worrying about whether my pension would cover everything.
And now I was being asked to explain why I hadn't given away something I had purchased.
"I didn't do anything to you, honey."
She shook her head.
"You know I depend on that vehicle."
"I do."
"I need it every day."
"I understand."
"Then why are you bringing this up now?"
I looked at the white envelope in her purse.
"Because you brought up money first."
She frowned.
I continued.
"You gave me a bill for driving me to the doctor. You wanted three hundred and forty dollars. I paid you. I didn't argue about it."
She crossed her arms.
"That's different."
"How?"
"You're my mother. I was helping you."
I almost smiled.
Not because I found anything amusing.
Because I couldn't believe she had said that without hearing herself.
"That's exactly what I thought when I helped you buy this SUV."
She looked away.
Greg cleared his throat.
"Maybe we should slow down."
Jillian ignored him.
"Are you saying I owe you for the car?"
"No."
"Then what do you want?"
I took a moment.
I wanted her to understand that I wasn't trying to collect three years of payments.
I wasn't trying to turn our relationship into a business arrangement.
I wanted her to stop treating my help as something she was entitled to receive while treating her own help as something I had to purchase.
"I want us to be honest about the arrangement."
She gave a small laugh.
"There's nothing to discuss. I've been driving it."
"And I've been paying for it."
"That was your decision."
The words landed heavily.
That was your decision.
I looked at her.
"Yes, it was."
For a moment, I couldn't find anything else to say.
She had been right.
I had chosen to help her.
I had chosen to make the payments.
I had chosen not to remind her.
But I had never chosen to be treated like a customer.
Greg placed the title on the table.
"Jill, your mother helped you when you needed help. Maybe you should acknowledge that."
Jillian turned toward him.
"Don't start."
"I'm not starting anything."
"You don't understand."
He looked at her.
"I understand the paperwork."
Mitchell finally spoke.
"Mom, Grandma didn't have to buy you that vehicle."
Jillian's eyes narrowed.
"Mitchell, I already told you to stay out of this."
He lowered his voice.
"I'm just saying."
I reached for his hand.
"That's enough, sweetheart."
He looked at me.
I didn't want him defending me at the expense of his relationship with his mother.
He was young.
He had his own life to build.
I didn't want this argument becoming something he carried into every family gathering.
I turned back toward Jillian.
"Let's finish dinner."
She stared at me.
"You're serious?"
"Yes."
"You just showed me a title saying my car belongs to you, and now you want to eat pie?"
I nodded.
"Your pie is getting cold."
Greg almost smiled.
Mitchell looked down.
Jillian didn't move.
Eventually, she pushed her chair back and stood.
"I need some air."
She walked into the living room.
Greg followed her after a moment.
Mitchell stayed at the table.
He looked at the empty white envelope.
Then he looked at me.
"Grandma, I'm sorry."
I touched his cheek.
"You didn't do anything wrong."
"I just don't like the way she talks to you."
I swallowed.
"She's still your mother."
"I know."
"And she's still my daughter."
He nodded.
I could tell he wanted to say more.
But sometimes the kindest thing you can do is allow somebody to finish a difficult day without adding another argument.
We cleared the plates.
I wrapped the leftover roast.
I put the pie away.
When Jillian returned, she had her purse over her shoulder.
Greg was holding the brown envelope.
"Can I take this?" she asked.
I nodded.
"You can take a copy of everything."
She looked surprised.
"Why a copy?"
"Because the original title needs to stay somewhere safe."
She stared at me.
Then she handed the document back.
I carefully placed it inside the brown envelope.
"Take your time reading it."
She didn't answer.
At the door, Greg turned around.
"Thank you for dinner, Edith."
"You're welcome, Greg."
He looked like he wanted to say something else.
Instead, he nodded.
Jillian walked out first.
I watched through the window as she opened the SUV.
She sat behind the steering wheel.
For a few seconds, she didn't start the engine.
Then Greg climbed in.
The vehicle backed out of the driveway.
I stood there until it disappeared.
Mitchell was still in the kitchen.
He picked up his jacket.
"Do you want me to stay?"
I shook my head.
"Go home, sweetheart."
He hugged me.
"I'll call tomorrow."
"I'll be waiting."
After he left, I returned to the dining room.
The blue-flowered plates were still on the table.
One glass had a little gravy mark on the side.
The white envelope was empty.
I picked it up and placed it in the drawer.
Then I looked at the brown envelope.
I hadn't planned for Sunday to end that way.
I had imagined Jillian might apologize.
I had imagined she might say she hadn't thought about the payments.
I had even imagined she might laugh and admit that the whole situation had gotten out of hand.
Instead, she had asked why I was doing this to her.
That question stayed with me all evening.
I wondered whether she had ever considered what her bill had done to me.
I wondered whether she had thought about the fact that I was sitting in that passenger seat because I had followed my doctor's instructions.
I hadn't stopped driving because I wanted somebody to take care of me.
I had stopped because I wanted to stay alive.
There was a difference.
Before going to bed, I checked the front door twice.
Then I placed the brown envelope in my bedroom drawer.
I didn't want to lose the title.
But I didn't want to spend another night looking at it either.
I turned off the lamp.
And for the first time in a long while, I wondered whether being a good mother had made me a very poor judge of what I should accept.
Click here to continue reading: PART 6: The Next Morning My Daughter Called Before Breakfast, But She Wasn’t Calling to Ask Whether Her Mother’s Eyes Were Getting Worse
My Daughter Finally Put a Price on Helping Her Own Mother, But She Had No Idea What I Was About to Discover
Part 5 of 20
