The next few days felt longer than the previous six years.
I was waiting for the police to contact me.
I was also waiting for Dean to call.
Both possibilities made me nervous.
Sophie noticed.
She told me I didn't have to answer every call.
I knew that.
But avoiding Dean felt like admitting I was afraid of him.
I wasn't ready to do that.
Then the police called.
They wanted another meeting.
This time, they asked whether I could provide the photograph taken on the morning of the fishing trip.
I had kept it.
I brought the original photograph and a digital copy.
The investigator studied it.
He asked about the equipment visible in the background.
I explained what I could.
He asked whether the boat in the photograph was the same one later recovered across the lake.
I said it was.
He asked whether Daniel had made any changes to the boat before the trip.
I couldn't remember anything unusual.
The investigator explained that the original examination records were being reviewed alongside the new recordings.
He also asked whether Daniel had used the old phone during the final week.
I didn't know.
I told him the phone had supposedly been missing for years.
He asked whether I had ever seen it after Daniel replaced it.
I said no.
He made another note.
Then he asked about Dean's relationship with Daniel.
I explained that they were brothers.
They had grown up together.
They sometimes disagreed, but they remained close enough to see each other regularly.
I also told him Dean had become a major source of support after the disappearance.
The investigator listened carefully.
He asked whether Dean had ever discussed the recovered boat with me.
I said he had.
He had always accepted the accident explanation.
He never suggested that anything unusual might have happened.
The investigator didn't comment.
He simply thanked me.
After the meeting, I felt drained.
I returned home and placed the photograph on the table.
Sophie joined me.
We looked at the boys.
She pointed at Lucas.
"He was always making that face."
I smiled.
"He thought it was funny."
Then she pointed at Michael.
"He looks so grown-up there."
He had been.
Old enough to help his father.
Old enough to understand that something was wrong if the adults were arguing.
I wondered whether Michael had known anything about the disagreement between Daniel and Dean.
The thought made me uncomfortable.
I didn't want to imagine my oldest son being caught in something he couldn't understand.
I put the photograph away.
That evening, Dean sent a message asking whether we needed anything.
I didn't reply immediately.
Sophie told me I should keep the message.
I did.
It was ordinary.
There was nothing threatening in it.
But I had begun saving every communication.
Not because I wanted to build a case against him.
Because I no longer knew what mattered.
Two mornings later, an investigator called again.
He said they had located additional material from the original investigation.
There were records connected to the boat and the search.
He couldn't discuss every detail over the phone.
He asked me to come in.
I agreed.
At the station, they showed me photographs of the recovered boat.
I recognized the damage.
The boat had been examined after it washed ashore.
There were marks that investigators had documented.
They explained that the original evidence had not provided a complete account of what happened.
I asked whether the damage could establish how the boat had ended up there.
The investigator said they were reviewing that question.
He also told me they wanted to compare the old evidence with the recordings.
I asked whether they believed Dean had been involved.
He chose his words carefully.
"We are not making that conclusion at this stage."
I nodded.
I appreciated the honesty.
Then he asked whether Dean knew about the old phone.
I told him I had mentioned finding it.
I also explained that Dean had asked whether it still worked.
The investigator asked when.
I gave him the date.
He wrote it down.
Before I left, he told me not to confront Dean while the review was ongoing.
I agreed.
But I knew that would be difficult.
Dean had been part of our lives for six years.
He still had a key to the house.
He still knew our routines.
He knew when the girls were home.
He knew when I went shopping.
I couldn't suddenly treat him like a stranger without raising questions.
When I returned home, Sophie was waiting.
She asked what the investigators had said.
I told her they were reviewing the boat evidence.
She looked toward the kitchen drawer.
"Do you think Uncle Dean knows they're looking at him?"
I sat down.
"I think he knows we're no longer accepting everything he says."
That night, I dreamed about the lake.
I saw the truck near the boat ramp.
The trailer was attached.
The water was still.
I called for Daniel.
No answer.
Then I saw Dean standing on the opposite shore.
I woke before I could reach him.
The next morning, I checked the locks on the doors.
I felt foolish doing it.
But I did it anyway.
I had trusted Dean for years.
Now I was beginning to understand how much of my daily life depended on that trust.
Click here to continue reading: PART 12: The Investigators Asked About One Final Conversation Between the Brothers, and I Realized I Had Forgotten Something Important
The Sunday Night My Husband and Three Sons Failed to Come Home, Leaving Me With a Photograph I Could Never Put Away
Part 11 of 20
