PART 10 – The Questions I Finally Took to the Police Were the Same Ones Dean Had Spent Years Telling Me Never to Ask

Sophie and I agreed that we couldn't investigate everything ourselves.

We had recordings.

We had dates.

We had a reason to ask for the original disappearance investigation to be reviewed.

But we needed someone who could examine the evidence properly.

I contacted the police department that had handled the original case.

I explained that we had discovered an old cellphone belonging to my husband.

I told them it contained recordings made shortly before he disappeared.

The officer asked whether the recordings involved the disappearance.

I said they appeared to.

He arranged for us to come in.

I barely slept the night before the appointment.

I kept imagining someone telling me the recordings meant nothing.

Or worse, that they were too damaged to establish anything.

Sophie came with me.

We carried the phone and the copies in a small bag.

At the station, an officer took us into a private room.

He listened without interrupting.

I explained how we had found the device.

I told him about the date of the first recording.

Then I described what we had heard.

He asked whether we had altered the files.

I said we had only made copies.

He asked where the original phone was.

I handed it over.

He examined it carefully.

Then he asked whether I recognized the man in the first video.

I answered immediately.

"That's my husband's brother, Dean."

The officer wrote something down.

He asked whether Dean had been present during the original investigation.

I told him about the help he had given us afterward.

I also explained how he had repeatedly discouraged me from questioning the accident.

The officer listened.

He didn't tell me what to think.

He simply asked me to describe exactly what Dean had said.

I repeated the words I remembered.

You need to move on.

I had heard them so many times that I could almost imitate his voice.

The officer asked whether Dean had ever been considered a suspect.

I didn't know.

I said I had never been told that he was.

He explained that the recordings would need to be examined.

They would also need to establish whether the voices and dates were authentic.

I understood.

I didn't expect an immediate answer.

Before leaving, I asked whether the original investigation could be reopened.

He said the new information would be reviewed.

He couldn't promise an outcome.

I thanked him.

On the way home, Sophie held my hand.

I felt strangely tired.

Not relieved.

Not yet.

I had spent six years waiting for someone to take my questions seriously.

Now someone finally had.

But that didn't mean we were closer to finding Daniel and the boys.

It only meant the questions had somewhere to go.

Two days later, I received a call from the officer.

He said investigators wanted to speak with me again.

They had reviewed the recordings.

They were interested in the conversation involving Dean.

I asked whether they had found anything else.

He said they were examining the original case records.

They also wanted to understand Daniel's movements during the day before the fishing trip.

I agreed to return.

During the second meeting, they asked about Daniel's habits.

I explained how carefully he prepared for travel.

I described his knowledge of the lake.

I told them about the truck, the fuel, the weather checks, and the emergency equipment.

One investigator asked whether Daniel had ever expressed concern about his brother.

I hesitated.

Then I told them what I remembered.

There had been a few uncomfortable conversations over the years.

Nothing I had considered serious at the time.

Daniel sometimes became quiet after speaking with Dean.

Once, he had told me he wished his brother would stop asking him for favors.

I hadn't thought much about it.

Families had disagreements.

Brothers argued.

I assumed they would work things out.

The investigator wrote that down.

He asked whether I remembered any specific disagreement before the disappearance.

I said I couldn't identify one.

But the recordings suggested something had happened.

He agreed.

Then he asked whether Dean had access to Daniel's old belongings.

I explained that Dean had helped around the house after the tragedy.

He had been in the garage.

He had repaired things.

He had carried boxes.

I couldn't say whether he had ever handled the old phone.

I felt uncomfortable admitting that.

For six years, I had allowed him to help without questioning his intentions.

The investigator didn't criticize me.

He said they would examine the evidence.

When the meeting ended, I asked one final question.

"Do you think my husband was planning to tell me something?"

The investigator paused.

"We can't know that yet."

I nodded.

I understood.

But on the drive home, I couldn't stop thinking about Daniel's final recording.

He had mentioned the girls.

He had asked me to look after them.

I wondered whether those words had been a goodbye.

Or whether he had simply been afraid of something that he thought might happen.

That evening, Dean called.

I watched his name appear on the screen.

For a moment, I considered letting it ring.

Then I answered.

He asked how I was.

I said I was fine.

He asked whether Sophie was home.

I said yes.

Then he asked something I hadn't expected.

"Have you spoken to the police lately?"

My fingers tightened around the phone.

I looked at Sophie.

She was standing in the doorway.

"Why do you ask?"

Dean paused.

"I was just wondering."

I didn't answer.

He told me he had heard someone had contacted the department about the old case.

I felt my heartbeat quicken.

He knew.

Or he suspected.

I kept my voice steady.

"I've had some new information."

There was silence.

Then Dean asked what kind of information.

I told him I wasn't ready to discuss it.

He said he understood.

But his voice had changed.

And for the first time, I didn't feel grateful when he offered to help.

I felt afraid.


Click here to continue reading: PART 11: Dean’s Familiar Voice No Longer Comforted Me, Especially After Investigators Began Looking Again at the Missing Boat

Story Parts

The Sunday Night My Husband and Three Sons Failed to Come Home, Leaving Me With a Photograph I Could Never Put Away

Part 10 of 20

Previous: Part 9
Next: Part 11

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *