I barely slept after Dean's phone call.
His words kept returning to me.
Be careful.
You don't want to put yourself through all that again.
I had heard similar things from him for six years.
But this time, I couldn't hear concern in his voice.
I heard something else.
Fear, perhaps.
Or maybe I was simply beginning to recognize how much I had ignored.
The following morning, Sophie found me sitting at the kitchen table.
The old photograph was beside my coffee cup.
She looked at it, then at me.
"Did you sleep?"
"Not much."
She pulled out a chair.
I told her about Dean's call again.
She listened without interrupting.
Then she asked whether I thought he knew what was on the phone.
I couldn't answer.
There was no way to know.
But he had asked about the device before.
He had seemed uncomfortable when I mentioned finding it.
And now he knew the police were reviewing the case.
I wondered whether he had been waiting for this moment for six years.
Or whether he had believed the old phone would never be discovered.
I didn't know.
A little after ten, the investigator called.
He asked whether I could come to the station again.
I agreed.
Sophie wanted to come with me.
This time, I accepted.
We arrived shortly before noon.
The investigator greeted us and led us into the same room.
There were several documents on the table.
He explained that they had been reviewing the original investigation alongside the recovered recordings.
He also told us that Dean had been contacted.
I felt my stomach tighten.
"Did he speak to you?"
The investigator nodded.
"He has answered some preliminary questions."
I waited.
He explained that they were trying to establish why Dean appeared in Daniel's recording and what the brothers had discussed before the fishing trip.
I asked whether Dean had provided an explanation.
The investigator said he couldn't share everything while the review was ongoing.
I understood.
Then he asked me to describe the last time I remembered seeing Daniel and Dean together.
I closed my eyes.
I remembered the kitchen.
The two coffee cups.
Daniel sitting at the table.
Dean standing near the back door.
They had stopped speaking when I entered.
I had asked whether they wanted more coffee.
Dean had said no.
Daniel had looked at me and smiled.
Nothing about the moment had seemed unusual.
Not enough to make me suspicious.
I told the investigator.
He wrote it down.
Then he asked whether I remembered Daniel saying anything afterward.
I thought for a moment.
"He told me he needed to settle something with his brother."
The investigator looked up.
"When was that?"
I tried to remember.
It was shortly before the fishing weekend.
I couldn't give an exact date.
But I was certain of the conversation.
The investigator added it to his notes.
Then he asked whether Daniel had ever discussed money problems involving Dean.
I hesitated.
I remembered Daniel complaining once that his brother had asked him for help.
I hadn't asked for details.
Daniel had said it wasn't my concern.
At the time, I thought he was simply protecting his brother's privacy.
I explained what I remembered.
The investigator asked whether there had been any arguments.
I said I couldn't recall a serious one.
He nodded.
Then he explained that they were examining the recordings further.
He also asked us to keep the original phone safe.
I told him it was already in their possession.
He said they would preserve the device and the recovered files.
I felt relieved.
For the first time, I wasn't carrying the entire burden of protecting Daniel's last recordings.
On the way home, Sophie asked whether the police had discovered anything important.
I told her they were still examining the evidence.
She looked out the window.
"I wish Dad had told us."
I understood.
I wished the same thing.
But I also knew Daniel might have had reasons for keeping the situation private.
I couldn't judge him without knowing what he had been facing.
That afternoon, I went into the boys' room.
I opened Michael's closet.
His fishing cap was still hanging there.
I touched the brim.
Then I remembered the last photograph.
Michael had worn that cap on the morning they left.
I wondered whether he had taken it with him.
I wondered whether it had been inside the boat.
I wondered whether the police had ever found it.
I had so many questions that I couldn't keep them straight.
I sat on the edge of his bed.
For six years, I had tried to accept that the boys were gone.
But accepting a loss was not the same as understanding it.
I wanted to know what happened.
I wanted to know why.
And I wanted to know why Daniel's brother had been part of something my husband seemed so afraid to discuss.
That evening, I put the photograph back on the shelf.
I didn't turn it toward the wall.
I left it facing the room.
Click here to continue reading: PART 14: When the Police Returned to the Original Case, I Learned How Many Questions Had Been Left Unanswered
The Sunday Night My Husband and Three Sons Failed to Come Home, Leaving Me With a Photograph I Could Never Put Away
Part 13 of 20

One Comment on “PART 13 – The Man Who Had Helped Me Raise Three Daughters Was Finally Asked to Explain His Last Conversation With Daniel”