PART 10 – The Questions I Had Never Thought to Ask About My First Love Suddenly Became Impossible to Ignore

I leaned forward.

I wanted Anna to continue.

She asked me whether I remembered the last serious conversation we had before our relationship ended.

I told her I remembered the important parts.

I had received the opportunity to move.

I had asked her to come with me.

I had proposed because I thought we could build a life together.

She had refused.

Those were the facts I had carried.

Anna listened.

Then she asked whether I had ever wondered why she had refused.

I told her I had.

Of course I had.

But I thought I knew the answer.

I was leaving.

She didn't want to leave with me.

That seemed reasonable enough.

At twenty years old, I hadn't known how to make two different futures fit together.

I had been disappointed.

But I had accepted her decision.

Anna said there was something I hadn't understood.

I looked at her.

She seemed almost afraid to continue.

I asked her whether I had done something wrong.

She shook her head.

That answer confused me even more.

I had spent years thinking that perhaps I hadn't been enough for her.

Perhaps she hadn't loved me as deeply as I had loved her.

Perhaps my proposal had come at the wrong time.

I had never said those things aloud to anyone.

But they were thoughts I had carried.

Anna seemed to understand.

She told me that the way things had ended had not been as simple as I remembered.

I asked her why she had let me believe otherwise.

She looked away.

Then she said that she had her reasons.

I wasn't satisfied.

I told her that I wasn't twenty anymore.

I wasn't asking her to reconsider anything.

I wasn't asking her to explain why she hadn't married me.

That part of our lives was over.

I was asking because my wife had made this her final request.

I needed to know what Carol had wanted me to understand.

Anna nodded.

She said she knew.

Then she asked me something unexpected.

Had Carol ever spoken about Anna during our marriage?

I thought about it.

Not that I could remember.

I told her that the name had almost never come up.

In fact, before that hospital conversation, I couldn't remember Carol mentioning her at all.

Anna listened.

Then she asked whether I had ever told Carol about my proposal.

I said yes.

Not in great detail.

But Carol knew Anna had been my first love.

She knew we had once been serious.

She knew I had wanted to marry her.

And she knew our relationship had ended when I moved.

I had never considered those details a secret.

They were simply part of my life before Carol.

Anna nodded slowly.

Then she asked whether I had ever thought Carol might have known more than I had told her.

I stared at her.

I didn't know how to answer.

I had trusted Carol.

I had never felt the need to question what she knew about my past.

I had no reason to suspect that she was hiding anything connected to Anna.

But now I was sitting in Anna's home, being asked to reconsider that assumption.

I felt a strange mixture of sadness and confusion.

I didn't want to think badly of my wife.

Not after losing her.

But I couldn't ignore what Anna was telling me.

I asked her whether Carol had ever explained why she wanted me to find her.

Anna said she had.

That answer made me sit completely still.

I asked when.

She said there had been conversations.

I wanted to know what they had discussed.

Anna looked at me for a long moment.

Then she said she would explain.

But she wanted me to understand that Carol's intentions had not been cruel.

I looked at her.

I didn't know whether that was supposed to comfort me.

I only knew that the woman I had loved for thirty-six years had left me with a question that another woman from my past was finally beginning to answer.


Click here to continue reading: PART 11: I Began to Understand Why My Wife Had Asked for Forgiveness, but I Still Couldn’t See the Whole Picture

Story Parts

The Promise My Wife Made Me Carry Was the Last Thing I Expected to Hear From Her

Part 10 of 20

Previous: Part 9
Next: Part 11

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *