Anna took a moment before speaking again.
I could see that she was struggling with something.
I didn't know whether it was sadness or uncertainty.
Perhaps both.
I sat quietly.
There was no point pretending I wasn't nervous.
My wife's final request had brought me to a house four hours away.
And the woman sitting across from me seemed to know more than I did.
I asked her to explain.
She looked at me.
Then she said that Carol's request had not surprised her in the way I might imagine.
I didn't understand.
I asked what she meant.
Anna paused.
She told me that she knew there was a reason Carol had wanted me to come.
I felt my stomach tighten.
I asked whether she and Carol had been in contact.
Anna didn't immediately answer.
I thought about how strange that possibility was.
For almost forty years, I had believed Anna was completely outside my life.
I had no idea that my wife might have known something about her.
And now I was sitting in front of her, trying to understand how that could be possible.
I asked Anna how she knew Carol.
She looked down at her hands.
Then she looked at me again.
She said that I deserved to hear the truth.
I remember those words.
They sounded simple.
But they made me realize that whatever came next wasn't going to be an ordinary conversation between two people remembering college.
I asked her to continue.
She took a breath.
I watched her carefully.
There were so many things I wanted to ask.
How long had she known?
Why hadn't I heard anything?
Why had Carol waited until the end?
But I didn't want to interrupt.
I wanted the explanation in the order Anna needed to give it.
She asked me whether I remembered the time when she had turned down my proposal.
I told her I remembered.
I couldn't forget something like that.
I remembered being young.
I remembered believing we might get married.
And I remembered how disappointed I had been when she refused.
I had always understood her decision as a choice she had made because I was leaving.
I had never thought there was another explanation.
Anna listened.
Then she told me that there were things from that period I had never known.
I sat back.
My first reaction was disbelief.
What could there possibly be?
I had been there.
I had lived through the relationship.
I had asked her to marry me.
She had said no.
We had separated.
What was missing?
Anna didn't rush to answer.
She seemed to understand that I needed time to take in what she was saying.
I thought about Carol again.
Her weak voice in the hospital.
Her fingers holding mine.
The way she had asked me to forgive her.
At the time, I had thought she was asking me to forgive some personal mistake.
Perhaps something she had done in our marriage.
But now I wasn't sure.
I asked Anna whether Carol had told her something about me.
She looked at me.
Then she said that there was a reason she needed to be careful with what she told me.
I didn't like hearing that.
I had spent too many weeks living with questions.
I didn't want another conversation full of half-answers.
I told her that I wasn't a young man anymore.
I didn't need anybody to protect me from an uncomfortable truth.
If there was something I should know, I wanted to hear it.
Anna nodded.
She seemed to accept that.
Then she said she would explain what she could.
I looked at her and waited.
I didn't know what I was about to learn.
But I knew one thing.
Carol had not spoken Anna's name by accident.
And Anna knew that too.
Click here to continue reading: PART 8: I Had Driven Four Hours Looking for an Explanation, but the Truth Was Already Changing Everything I Believed
The Promise My Wife Made Me Carry Was the Last Thing I Expected to Hear From Her
Part 7 of 20
