PART 17 – Anna Finally Explained Why Carol Had Known About Our Old Relationship and Why She Had Asked Me to Come

Anna took another breath.

I could tell she had reached the part of the conversation she had been avoiding.

I sat quietly.

There was no reason to rush her.

I had waited nearly forty years without knowing this story.

I could wait a few more minutes.

She looked at me and said that Carol had eventually come to understand something about the past that neither of us had expected.

I asked her to explain.

Anna said she and Carol had shared conversations about what happened years earlier.

I still found that difficult to imagine.

My wife and my first love.

Two women whose lives I had believed were completely separate.

Yet they had apparently spoken about a part of my history that I thought was finished.

I asked whether Carol had been upset when she first learned about it.

Anna said that Carol had experienced many feelings.

I wanted to know which ones.

She said it wasn't her place to describe every private conversation between them.

I understood.

But I also wanted to hear what mattered.

Anna told me that Carol had eventually realized there was something I had never understood about the way Anna and I separated.

I looked at her.

I had heard that several times already.

Now I needed the explanation.

Anna said she had never wanted me to believe that I hadn't mattered to her.

That sentence hurt more than I expected.

I looked away.

For almost forty years, I had accepted that she had chosen not to share my future.

I hadn't spent every day thinking about it.

But somewhere inside me, I had kept the memory of that rejection.

I asked her whether she had really wanted to marry me back then.

Anna looked down.

She said that the feelings we had shared were real.

I waited for more.

She didn't immediately continue.

I asked whether my move had been the only reason she had turned me down.

Anna said there had been more to the situation than I had understood.

I felt my heart beating faster.

I asked what that meant.

She told me that I needed to remember how young we were.

We were making decisions with very little experience.

Neither of us could see how those decisions would affect the rest of our lives.

I agreed.

But that still didn't explain the secret.

I told her so.

Anna nodded.

Then she said Carol had wanted her to tell me because she believed I deserved to know the truth.

I thought about my wife's final days.

I remembered how she had struggled to speak.

I remembered her asking me to forgive her.

Perhaps she had been trying to find the courage to say something she had carried for years.

I asked Anna whether Carol had ever regretted becoming involved in the situation.

She said Carol had regretted allowing the truth to remain unresolved.

I looked at her.

That was different from what I had imagined.

I had wondered whether my wife had done something deliberately cruel.

I had imagined all sorts of things during those lonely weeks.

But Anna wasn't describing Carol as someone who had wanted to hurt me.

She was describing someone who had carried a difficult burden.

I asked whether Anna blamed Carol.

She shook her head.

She said that blaming someone wasn't going to change what had happened.

I understood that too.

I had spent enough time grieving to know that some questions had no useful answers.

Still, I needed to know what had actually happened.

I asked Anna to stop holding back.

She looked at me.

Then she said she would tell me everything she could.

I leaned forward.

My hands were resting on my knees.

I wasn't thinking about the drive anymore.

I wasn't thinking about the house or the time.

I was thinking about Carol.

And about the woman sitting across from me who had apparently been connected to my wife's final wish for much longer than I knew.


Click here to continue reading: PART 18: The Truth About My Wife’s Apology Was Not What I Had Imagined During Those Lonely Weeks After Her Death

Story Parts

The Promise My Wife Made Me Carry Was the Last Thing I Expected to Hear From Her

Part 17 of 20

Previous: Part 16
Next: Part 18

One Comment on “PART 17 – Anna Finally Explained Why Carol Had Known About Our Old Relationship and Why She Had Asked Me to Come”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *