Anna sat quietly for another moment.
I could tell she was trying to decide where to begin.
I had already told her everything about Carol's final request.
Now I needed her to tell me what she knew.
She looked at me and asked whether I was ready to hear something difficult.
I almost laughed.
My wife had died.
I had spent weeks wondering why she had sent me there.
I had driven four hours to find a woman from my past.
I wasn't sure how much more difficult things could become.
But I nodded.
"Please tell me."
Anna folded her hands.
She said she had known about Carol for a long time.
That was the first thing that surprised me.
I asked her how that was possible.
She didn't answer immediately.
Instead, she reminded me that nearly forty years had passed since our college days.
A lot had happened during that time.
People had changed.
Lives had moved forward.
And there were things that had remained hidden.
I told her I understood that.
But I wanted to know what any of it had to do with my marriage.
Anna looked at me.
She said Carol had eventually become an important part of a story that neither of us had expected.
I felt uncomfortable hearing that.
Carol had been my wife.
I had known her for thirty-six years.
I thought I understood our life together.
I had never imagined that there might be something connected to Anna that I didn't know.
I asked whether Carol had contacted her.
Anna nodded.
I waited for her to explain.
She told me that Carol had known who Anna was.
I asked how.
Anna said that she didn't want me to misunderstand.
She wasn't suggesting that Carol had spent our marriage worrying about my old relationship.
That wasn't what she meant.
I listened carefully.
Then she said that the connection between them was much more complicated than I had assumed.
I asked her to be direct.
She looked down at her hands again.
I could see that this wasn't easy for her either.
Then she began talking about the past.
She mentioned the time when Anna and I had been together.
She remembered the proposal.
She remembered that I had planned to leave for another state.
And she remembered that our relationship had ended.
I told her that I remembered all of it.
But she said there was more to that period than I knew.
I asked what I had missed.
Anna paused.
Then she said she had never forgotten the way things ended.
Neither had I.
But I had always believed that the decision was hers.
She had turned me down.
I had left.
And life had continued.
Anna looked at me.
She said she understood why I remembered it that way.
But there were details I had never been told.
I felt my throat tighten.
I wanted to know why she hadn't told me before.
Why wait nearly forty years?
Why let me spend all those years believing something that might not have been true?
Anna didn't immediately answer.
She said that some things had been difficult to explain even at the time.
I looked at the floor.
I thought about Carol's face in the hospital.
Her request.
Her apology.
Perhaps I had misunderstood the apology completely.
I asked Anna whether Carol had known the full story.
She nodded.
And that was when I realized my wife's final request was not simply about two people who had once been in love.
It was about something that had remained between them for years.
Something Carol wanted me to hear.
Click here to continue reading: PART 10: The Questions I Had Never Thought to Ask About My First Love Suddenly Became Impossible to Ignore
The Promise My Wife Made Me Carry Was the Last Thing I Expected to Hear From Her
Part 9 of 20
