I had another question.
It had been bothering me since Anna mentioned Carol's connection to the past.
I asked how long the two of them had known each other.
Anna didn't answer immediately.
She looked at me as if she understood why I was asking.
I told her that I had never known about any relationship between them.
Not once during my thirty-six years of marriage had I suspected that Carol and Anna had some connection.
Anna said she understood.
Then she explained that the circumstances surrounding their connection were not something she could describe in one sentence.
I felt frustrated again.
I wasn't angry with her.
I was simply tired of having to guess.
I told her that I had come all this way because my wife had asked me to.
I had lost Carol.
I couldn't ask her anything anymore.
If Anna knew the answers, I needed her to tell me.
She nodded.
Then she began talking about Carol.
She described her as someone who had wanted to do the right thing.
I almost smiled sadly.
That sounded like the woman I had known.
Carol had never been perfect.
Neither had I.
But she had been the person I trusted most.
I asked whether Carol had felt guilty about something.
Anna looked down.
She said that guilt had been part of the reason Carol wanted us to meet.
I felt my chest tighten.
I asked what she had done.
Anna said she didn't want me to misunderstand her explanation.
I told her I would listen.
She said Carol had carried certain knowledge about my past for a long time.
I asked whether that knowledge had affected our marriage.
Anna shook her head.
She didn't want me to believe that our entire marriage had been built around some secret.
She said the years Carol and I shared were real.
I appreciated hearing that.
I didn't need anyone to tell me that my marriage had meant nothing.
It had meant everything.
I had loved Carol.
And I still loved her, even though she was gone.
But I needed to understand why she had asked me to forgive her.
Anna said that Carol had wanted to make sure the truth didn't disappear with her.
That sentence stayed with me.
I looked at her.
I thought about how easily things could be lost when nobody spoke about them.
A person died.
A memory disappeared.
A question remained unanswered.
Carol had known that.
Perhaps she had realized she was running out of time.
I asked Anna whether she and Carol had discussed me during those years.
She said they had spoken about the past.
I asked whether Carol had ever told her how happy we were.
Anna nodded.
She said Carol had spoken about our marriage.
I looked down.
That was difficult to hear.
I didn't know why.
Perhaps because it made the connection feel more real.
Anna knew something about the woman I had loved.
And Carol had apparently known something about Anna.
They had both carried pieces of a story that I was only now beginning to understand.
I asked whether Anna had ever wanted to contact me.
She looked at me for a moment.
Then she said there had been reasons she hadn't.
I didn't press her immediately.
I could see she was trying to be honest.
But I also knew that there was still more.
I asked whether she had ever regretted the way we separated.
She didn't give me a simple yes or no.
Instead, she said that life had taught her that people sometimes make decisions without knowing what those decisions will cost.
I understood that.
I had made plenty of decisions in my own life.
Some had worked out.
Some hadn't.
But I had never imagined that one decision from my twenties could still matter so much decades later.
Anna told me that Carol wanted me to hear everything from the beginning.
Not just the ending I remembered.
I nodded.
For the first time, I stopped trying to guess what the revelation might be.
I decided to let Anna tell it in her own way.
Click here to continue reading: PART 15: My Wife’s Request Was Beginning to Make Sense, but the Reason Behind Her Apology Still Hurt
The Promise My Wife Made Me Carry Was the Last Thing I Expected to Hear From Her
Part 14 of 20

One Comment on “PART 14 – I Asked Anna Why Two Women Had Carried a Secret About My Past While I Went On Living Without Knowing”