Anna continued speaking.
She told me that Carol had wanted the past to be faced honestly.
I asked whether there was something specific she had hidden from me.
Anna said that the situation involved the way our lives had changed after my relationship with her ended.
I listened.
I tried to keep my mind open.
I didn't want to fill in the missing details with assumptions.
She reminded me that I had left for another state.
I told her I remembered.
She said that my departure had been an important turning point.
I agreed.
But I still couldn't understand why Carol would have needed to apologize for it.
I asked whether Carol had somehow been involved in our separation.
Anna paused.
I watched her face.
She didn't immediately give me a clear answer.
Instead, she explained that Carol had learned about the past and had carried the knowledge for a long time.
I asked whether she meant Carol had known Anna before I married her.
Anna said their connection had developed through circumstances connected to that old chapter.
I was still confused.
I told her that I couldn't understand how any of this had remained unknown to me for so many years.
Anna said that sometimes people believe they are protecting others by keeping quiet.
I looked down.
That sounded familiar.
Carol had been a private person about certain things.
But I had never thought of her as someone who would hide something important from me.
I asked Anna whether she thought Carol had made the wrong decision.
She said that Carol herself had eventually struggled with that question.
I felt sadness more than anger.
I pictured Carol sitting somewhere, thinking about something she had never told me.
I wondered whether she had wanted to speak many times.
Perhaps she had even started a conversation and then changed her mind.
I would never know.
I asked Anna whether Carol had been worried I would hate her after learning the truth.
Anna said that she had been concerned about hurting me.
I rubbed my forehead.
I was already hurting.
But not because I had stopped loving Carol.
I was hurting because I had lost the chance to hear her explain herself.
I told Anna that I wished my wife had trusted me.
She listened.
Then she said that Carol had wanted to make things right before she died.
I asked whether that was why she had made the request.
Anna nodded.
I sat quietly.
The hospital room came back to me.
I remembered the way Carol had squeezed my hand.
I remembered the unusual seriousness in her voice.
I remembered thinking that she was asking me to do something strange.
Now I wondered whether she had been trying to give me something she had held back for years.
An explanation.
A chance to understand.
I asked Anna whether Carol had told her exactly what to say.
She said Carol hadn't wanted the conversation to become a performance.
She wanted Anna to speak honestly.
I appreciated that.
I didn't want rehearsed words.
I wanted the truth.
Anna told me that she knew I had spent years believing our old relationship ended because I was leaving and she didn't want to follow.
I nodded.
That was exactly what I believed.
She said that the memory had stayed with both of them in different ways.
I asked what she meant.
Anna looked at me.
She said that I had not been the only person affected by what happened.
I felt my chest tighten.
For the first time, I began to understand that the story might have consequences beyond my own disappointment.
I asked her to explain what she meant by that.
She looked down at her hands.
Then she said she wanted to make sure I understood one thing first.
Carol had loved me.
I nodded.
I knew that.
But hearing Anna say it still brought tears to my eyes.
Click here to continue reading: PART 19: I Finally Understood Why Carol Had Sent Me to Anna, but Understanding Her Was Not the Same as Losing My Questions
The Promise My Wife Made Me Carry Was the Last Thing I Expected to Hear From Her
Part 18 of 20
