There was a long silence.
I sat across from Anna, waiting for her to continue.
The room seemed unusually quiet.
I could hear small sounds from elsewhere in the house.
But neither of us spoke.
I kept thinking about the years that had passed.
Thirty-six years of marriage.
Nearly forty years since Anna and I had separated.
Two different periods of my life that I had always believed were completely separate.
Now they were sitting together in the same room.
I asked Anna to tell me what she knew.
She looked at me for a moment.
Then she said that she had never wanted my visit to happen under these circumstances.
I understood what she meant.
If Carol hadn't been dying, I might never have come looking for Anna.
And if Carol hadn't made that request, I might never have known there was anything to discover.
I told Anna that I wished my wife could have explained it herself.
I wished I could go back to that hospital room and ask her all the questions I hadn't managed to ask.
But I couldn't.
Carol was gone.
And I was left trying to understand her final words.
Anna lowered her eyes.
She said she was sorry about Carol.
I thanked her.
I meant it.
Then she asked me whether I still had any old photographs from college.
I thought about it.
I wasn't sure what I had kept over the years.
There were old belongings I had put away.
But I hadn't looked through them in a long time.
I told her that I might have a few.
Anna nodded.
She seemed to be thinking about something.
I asked why she wanted to know.
She didn't immediately explain.
Instead, she asked whether I remembered the circumstances surrounding our separation.
I told her again that I had received the opportunity to move for work.
I had asked her to come with me.
I had proposed.
She had refused.
That was the version of events I had carried for nearly forty years.
Anna listened.
Then she said that my memory of the ending was not necessarily the whole story.
I felt myself become tense.
I asked what she meant.
She looked directly at me.
I could see that she was taking this seriously.
I wanted to believe there was some simple explanation.
Perhaps something had happened that I had forgotten.
Perhaps she had misunderstood something back then.
But Anna wasn't speaking as if this were a minor misunderstanding.
She told me that there were things she had never explained to me.
I asked why.
She didn't give me an easy answer.
I thought about the young woman I had once known.
I thought about the proposal she had rejected.
And I wondered how much of that old story I had actually understood.
I had always assumed that our relationship ended because we wanted different things.
I had accepted it.
I had built another life.
But now Anna was telling me that the story I remembered was incomplete.
I looked at her.
"Was Carol involved in this?"
Anna became quiet again.
That question seemed to matter.
She took a breath.
Then she said that Carol had wanted me to hear the truth from her.
Not from a letter.
Not from somebody else.
From Anna herself.
I didn't know what to say.
My wife's final request suddenly felt much heavier.
I had thought I was fulfilling a simple promise by finding an old girlfriend.
But I was beginning to understand that Carol had sent me here for a reason she had never been able to explain.
And I had finally reached the person who could.
I sat still.
I waited for Anna to continue.
For the first time, I wasn't thinking about the four-hour drive home.
I was thinking about the years behind me.
And about how little I might have understood.
Click here to continue reading: PART 9: Anna Finally Began Explaining Why Carol Had Sent Me to Her Door After Nearly Forty Years Apart
The Promise My Wife Made Me Carry Was the Last Thing I Expected to Hear From Her
Part 8 of 20
