Anna stood up briefly.
She asked whether I wanted something to drink.
I told her I was fine.
She returned to her seat.
The conversation had become difficult, but I didn't want to stop.
I had spent too long wondering.
Now I needed to hear everything Anna was willing to tell me.
She asked me to think carefully about the years when Carol and I first met.
I tried.
I remembered that period.
I remembered starting a new chapter of my life.
I had moved away from the place where Anna and I had gone to college.
I was building a different future.
Eventually, Carol entered my life.
Our relationship developed.
We married.
And I never looked back in the way Anna might have expected.
Anna listened as I described those years.
Then she said that Carol had eventually learned something about the past that affected her.
I asked what she meant.
Anna hesitated.
She said that Carol had carried certain feelings for a long time.
I didn't understand.
I asked whether Carol had been jealous of Anna.
Anna shook her head.
She said it wasn't quite that.
I found myself becoming frustrated.
Every answer seemed to lead to another question.
I told her I needed her to stop speaking around the subject.
I had buried my wife.
I had come there because she asked me to.
I didn't want another mystery.
Anna looked at me.
Then she said she understood.
She told me that Carol had wanted the truth to reach me eventually.
I asked why she hadn't told me herself.
Anna said that she had her own reasons for waiting.
I thought about the hospital room again.
Carol had been weak.
She had been struggling to speak.
Perhaps she had known she wouldn't have enough time to explain everything.
Perhaps that was why she had made me promise to find Anna.
I asked whether Carol had known she was going to die when she made the request.
Anna said that she couldn't answer what Carol had known at that exact moment.
But she understood why the request had become urgent.
I looked at her.
There was something painful in the way she spoke about Carol.
She wasn't talking about my wife as an enemy.
She seemed to have some understanding of what Carol had been going through.
I asked her whether she had forgiven Carol.
Anna didn't answer immediately.
Then she said that forgiveness wasn't a simple thing.
I understood that.
I had just lost someone I loved.
I knew how complicated feelings could become when there was no chance to ask another question.
I told Anna that Carol had asked me to forgive her.
I wanted to know what that meant.
Anna looked at me.
She said that Carol had wanted me to understand why certain things had happened.
I asked whether she meant the ending of my relationship with Anna.
She nodded.
I felt a heaviness in my chest.
For almost forty years, I had believed I understood that ending.
Now I was being told there was another side.
I asked Anna whether the decision to refuse my proposal had really been hers.
She looked down.
I waited.
Then she said that the circumstances had been more complicated than I knew.
I didn't speak.
I could hear my own breathing.
I remembered being twenty.
I remembered the hope I had felt when I asked her to marry me.
I remembered the disappointment afterward.
I had spent years believing that I simply hadn't been the person she wanted.
And suddenly I wondered whether I had been wrong about that too.
Anna told me she didn't want me to blame myself for what had happened.
I looked at her.
I hadn't even realized I was doing that.
But perhaps I had been.
I asked her to tell me what Carol knew.
Anna said she would.
And this time, I could see she was preparing to speak more plainly.
Click here to continue reading: PART 12: The Past I Thought I Had Accepted Was Suddenly Standing Between Me and the Life I Had Shared With Carol
The Promise My Wife Made Me Carry Was the Last Thing I Expected to Hear From Her
Part 11 of 20
